
Consumer Proposal vs. Bankruptcy: How to Choose in Canada
When debt payments stop fitting your income, Canadian insolvency law gives you two formal ways to reset: a consumer proposal or personal bankruptcy. Both are handled through a Licensed Insolvency Trustee (LIT) and both can stop collection calls quickly, but they work very differently and leave different marks behind. Here is how each one actually functions, so you can walk into a trustee consultation already understanding the basics.
The two options, in one line each
A consumer proposal is a negotiated deal: you offer creditors a portion of what you owe, paid over time, and if enough of them agree, the rest of that debt is legally wiped out once you finish paying.
Bankruptcy is a formal legal process where you give up certain assets and surplus income in exchange for having most unsecured debts eliminated, typically within nine months to a couple of years depending on your income and whether it's a first bankruptcy.
- Both require a Licensed Insolvency Trustee, the only professional in Canada legally authorized to administer either process.
- Both trigger an automatic stay of proceedings that generally stops creditor calls, most lawsuits, and most wage garnishments as soon as you file.
Keep reading: Loan Payment Calculator · Savings Goal Calculator. For the official rules, see Financial Consumer Agency of Canada.
How a consumer proposal works
You and your trustee put together an offer to your unsecured creditors, usually a lump sum or monthly payments spread over a period of up to five years, for less than the full amount owed.
Creditors vote on the proposal. If a majority (by dollar value) of those who vote accept it, the terms become binding on all your unsecured creditors, including any who voted no or didn't vote at all.
You keep your assets as long as you continue making the agreed payments and stay current on any secured debt, such as a car loan or mortgage, tied to those assets.
Eligibility is capped by total unsecured debt, and there's a legislated dollar threshold set out in the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act — a trustee can confirm the exact current limit and whether your debt load qualifies.
How bankruptcy works
You transfer your non-exempt assets to your trustee, who liquidates them for the benefit of creditors. Each province sets its own list of exempt assets — often including basic household goods, some equity in a vehicle, and tools of the trade — so what you actually lose varies by where you live.
If your income is above a threshold the trustee calculates based on family size, you'll also be required to make surplus income payments for part of the process, which can extend a first bankruptcy beyond the usual nine months.
Most unsecured debts — credit cards, lines of credit, payday loans, most tax debt — are discharged at the end. Some debts, like most student loans within the first several years after you leave school, court fines, and family support obligations, are not wiped out.
A second or later bankruptcy takes longer to discharge than a first one, which is one reason trustees often steer repeat filers toward a proposal instead.
What actually decides between them
Assets you want to keep are the biggest factor. If you have home equity, a newer vehicle, or other assets above your province's exemption limits, a consumer proposal lets you keep them by paying creditors instead of surrendering property.
Income matters too. If your income is comfortably above the surplus threshold, bankruptcy can mean months of surplus payments, sometimes making a proposal the cheaper and faster route even though it isn't a full discharge.
Credit impact differs. A completed consumer proposal is generally viewed as a lighter mark than a bankruptcy and tends to drop off your credit report sooner after completion, though a first bankruptcy also clears in a defined number of years. Exact retention periods are set by the credit bureaus, not the government, and can change — confirm current timelines with your trustee rather than assuming a number.
- Debt type matters: if a large share of your debt is secured (mortgage, car loan) or excluded from discharge (recent student loans, support payments), neither option erases it, and you'll want that mapped out before choosing.
- Cost and control differ too: a proposal generally costs more upfront in trustee fees relative to what you'd pay in a straightforward bankruptcy, but it gives you a fixed, predictable payment and no asset liquidation.
Getting started the right way
Every Licensed Insolvency Trustee in Canada is required to offer a free initial consultation, and that conversation — not a debt consultant, credit counsellor selling a different product, or a Google search — is the right first step, since a trustee can run the numbers on your actual debts, assets, and income.
Bring a list of everything you owe, your pay stubs or recent tax return, and a rough sense of what you own, including any home or vehicle equity, so the trustee can tell you which option you'd even qualify for.
Neither option is something to back into gradually through missed payments; the earlier you talk to a trustee, the more options — including ones short of formal insolvency, like a debt management plan through a non-profit credit counselling agency — stay on the table.
Frequently asked
Will I lose my house or car if I file a consumer proposal?
Not automatically. A consumer proposal is designed to let you keep your assets as long as you keep up with the proposal payments and stay current on any secured debt, like a car loan or mortgage, tied to them. In bankruptcy, whether you keep an asset depends on your province's exemption rules and how much equity is in it — your trustee can tell you exactly what applies to you.
Does either option stop collection calls and wage garnishment?
Yes. Filing a consumer proposal or an assignment in bankruptcy triggers a legal stay of proceedings that generally requires creditors to stop collection calls, most lawsuits, and most wage garnishments right away. A few exceptions, such as certain family support obligations, don't get paused — your trustee will flag anything that still applies.
Which one hurts my credit less?
A completed consumer proposal is generally considered less damaging and shorter-lived on your credit report than a bankruptcy, though both leave a mark for a period of years. Exact reporting timelines are set by the credit bureaus and can change, so confirm current numbers with a Licensed Insolvency Trustee or the Financial Consumer Agency of Canada rather than relying on a fixed figure.
Sources
General information for Canadian readers, not individualized financial, tax or investment advice. Figures reflect the date reviewed; confirm current limits and rules with the CRA or a qualified professional before acting.